Pembicaraan MediaWiki:Licenses

Komentar terbaru: 4 tahun yang lalu oleh MGA73 pada topik Update of licenses 2020

Om Sysop apakah ini tidak perlu di-update soalnya liat di Kategori:Templat lisensi gambar ada beberapa lisensi yang tidak dimasukkan di sini seperti lisensi CC-by-Sa, dll. Thx Athrion  09:08, 4 Mei 2009 (UTC)

Apa ada lagi yang kurang?
Bennylin
04:55, 24 Desember 2009 (UTC)

Cleanup in licenses

sunting

I think that a cleanup in licenses is needed.

Per Wikimedia Foundation resolution it is NOT ALLOWED to have non-commercial or no-derivate files on Wikipedia. So the licenses that include "nc" or "nd" should be removed from the list of licenses.

WMF decided long ago that GFDL was not a good license so they changed to Cc-by-sa-3.0. Therefore GFDL should be avoided whenever possible. So we should not make GFDL the first suggestion. We should suggest Cc-by-sa-3.0 or a dual license with GFDL|Cc-by-sa-3.0. If users want to use GFDL alone they should add it manually.

Therefore I suggest these changes:

  • Lisensi bebas, karya Anda sendiri:
    • GFDL-self|GFDL - remove
    • Self|Cc-by-3.0|Beri atribusi - make this the second one
    • Self|Cc-by-nc-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak untuk komersial - remove
    • Self|Cc-by-nc-nd-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak untuk komersial, tidak boleh diturunkan - remove
    • Self|Cc-by-nc-sa-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak untuk komersial, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa - remove
    • Self|Cc-by-nd-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak boleh diturunkan - remove
    • Self|Cc-by-sa-3.0|Beri atribusi, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa - make this the first one
    • Self|Cc-by-sa-3.0|GFDL|Beri atribusi, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa - add and make this the third one
  • Lisensi bebas, karya orang lain: - add (remember to document the permission by link or mail to OTRS)
    • GFDL|GFDL (karya orang lain)
    • Cc-by-3.0|Beri atribusi
    • Cc-by-nc-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak untuk komersial - remove
    • Cc-by-nc-nd-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak untuk komersial, tidak boleh diturunkan - remove
    • Cc-by-nc-sa-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak untuk komersial, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa - remove
    • Cc-by-nd-3.0|Beri atribusi, tidak boleh diturunkan - remove
    • Cc-by-sa-3.0|Beri atribusi, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa
    • Tampilan-Wikipedia|Tampilan (screenshot) Wikipedia
  • Domain umum: - remove and move the choises up
    • DU|Domain umum - move down and ad a warning "Please choose another license or the file may be deleted soon"
    • DU-Seni|Domain umum (karya seni dua dimensi) - move up under "Lisensi bebas, karya orang lain"
    • DU-Lama|Domain umum (hak cipta sudah berakhir) - move up under "Lisensi bebas, karya orang lain"
    • DU-Pembuat|Domain umum oleh sang pembuat - move up under "Lisensi bebas, karya orang lain"
    • DU-Sendiri|Domain umum oleh saya - move up under "Lisensi bebas, karya Anda sendiri"

I did not check the rest of the license it is possible to choose. I also used google translate to assist so if something looks totally wrong that is probably why. --MGA73 (bicara) 24 Juli 2012 19.09 (UTC)Balas

I'm not sure about the text for asking people to send a ticket to OTRS. Is there any sample text that I can use? ‑Bennylin komunikasi 02.25, 25 Juli 2012 (WIB)
Hm... No I don´t think there is.. On lb:MediaWiki:Licenses there is a text "Denkt dru fir d'Autorisatioun ze dokumentéieren" meaning something like "remember to document the permission".
Is there a template like en:Template:Di-no permission somewhere? --MGA73 (bicara) 24 Juli 2012 19.29 (UTC)Balas

Here is a few otheres that should be removed:

--MGA73 (bicara) 25 Juli 2012 17.14 (UTC)Balas

  Selesai. ‑Bennylin bicara 00.28, 26 Juli 2012 (WIB)
Thanks to Mr. Benny.   Wagino 20100516 (bicara) 26 Juli 2012 04.47 (UTC)Balas

Perbaikan

sunting

Bagaimana daftar templat ini bisa diperbaiki? Apa saja yang harus diganti/ditambahkan/dihilangkan? ‑Bennylin mufakat 01.36, 29 Januari 2013 (WIB)

Update of licenses 2020

sunting

Hi!

I think it is time for an update (I only checked licenses for free files):

  • Lisensi bebas, karya Anda sendiri:
    • Self|Cc-by-sa-4.0|Beri atribusi, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa (CC-BY-SA) - updated from 3.0 to 4.0
    • Self|Cc-by-4.0|Beri atribusi (CC-BY) - updated from 3.0 to 4.0
    • Self|Cc-by-sa-4.0|GFDL|Beri atribusi, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa (CC-BY-SA / GFDL) - updated from 3.0 to 4.0 or REMOVE as GFDL is not a good license for photos
    • Self|CC0|Domain umum oleh saya (CC0) - Changed DU-Sendiri to CC0 (DU-Sendiri is not a real license)
  • Lisensi bebas, karya orang lain:
    • GFDL|GFDL (karya orang lain) - REMOVE because GFDL is not a good license for photos (if anyone really really need it they can add it manually)
    • Cc-by-4.0|Beri atribusi - updated from 3.0 to 4.0
    • Cc-by-sa-4.0|Beri atribusi, turunan gunakan lisensi serupa - updated from 3.0 to 4.0
    • Tampilan-Wikipedia|Tampilan (screenshot) Wikipedia
    • DU-Seni|Domain umum (karya seni dua dimensi)
    • DU-Lama|Domain umum (hak cipta sudah berakhir)
    • DU-Pembuat|Domain umum oleh sang pembuat
    • DU|Domain umum (pilih lisensi yang lain atau berkas Anda akan dihapus) - REMOVE because it seems that the template is almost never used correct (see below)
    • DU-tekslogo|Domain umum (bentuk atau teks sederhana)
    • DU-USGov-NASA|Domain umum oleh NASA
    • DU-USGov-Military-Army|Domain umum oleh Angkatan Darat AS
  • Penggunaan wajar:

...

I also think that there should be a page that suggest that users upload free files to Commons but that is another question. --MGA73 (bicara) 21 Mei 2020 09.50 (UTC)Balas

I suggested above that we add a page that point users to Commons but there IS such a page. It was just not visible to me as my languaage settings are English. So there is no need for a new page.
There was a notice about my suggestion here: Wikipedia:Warung_Kopi_(Semua)#Pembaruan_lisensi and Wikipedia:Warung_Kopi_(Kebijakan)#Pembaruan_lisensi and Wikipedia:Permintaan_perhatian_pengurus#Update_of_licenses. I see no comments there against.
I also suggest to remove: "DU" because it seems that most of the files in Kategori:Lisensi yang tidak lengkap are there when {{DU}} is not used correct. I just added that today so if it can not be implemented now its cool with me. --MGA73 (bicara) 14 Juni 2020 20.14 (UTC)Balas
Kembali ke halaman "Licenses".