Skenario Terbaik (New York Film Critics Circle Award)
1950an sunting
| Tahun | Pemenang | Penulis | Sumber |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1956 | Around the World in 80 Days | James Poe, John Farrow, dan S. J. Perelman | novel karya Jules Verne |
| 1957 | Tak ada penghargaan yang diberikan | ||
| 1958 | The Defiant Ones | Nedrick Young and Harold Jacob Smith | — |
| 1959 | Anatomy of a Murder | Wendell Mayes | novel karya Robert Traver |